[Bill]
Music Review: Carpenters [a. k. a. “The Carpenters”]
Do you have a guilty pleasure? I do. I daresay you will be surprised, or more likely disappointed, when I tell you. OK, I love The Carpenters, or more correctly simply “Carpenters”. This was a brother and sister duo that defied categorization. Rather like ABBA, but that is another story altogether…
Carpenters had the gross misfortune to be in the wrong place in the wrong time. Musically Karen Carpenter’s voice was arguably amongst the best in Pop/Rock, it is full and rich with amazing range. Alas, the times in which Karen and Richard [her brother and co-writer] performed were in no way conducive to their music. There was never any doubt as to Karen’s ability as a singer, for even critics will acknowledge her phenomenal voice. Rather the problem was the score—at least at the time. But think of those times if you will 1968-1982, a fourteen year period of upheaval and social unrest, scarcely guaranteed to be welcoming to smooth, harmonious and lyrical pop music with frankly gentle lyrics.
But there was always something missing and their music was gleefully derided as sugar-coated pop treacle, at the time I detested it. Now in 2012, in what was once the far away future, we are hopefully, most of us at least, somewhat more liberal in our attitudes. And by “liberal” I do not mean in the current misnomer for American politics. I mean in the definition of classic economic theory of say, John Stuart Mill; which is to say a freeing of oneself from unthinking orthodoxy. It is also regrettable that Karen was the first popular person to die from Anorexia, but back to the music, or my guilty pleasure…
Actually, I personally now believe that Karen and Richard knew exactly what they were doing at the time. As I continue to “bang on”; if you actually listen to the music you will be remarkably surprised. We at the WML have a collection of Carpenter singles 1968-1981. It is really excellent. Although they were at the time, the group you loved to hate, God knows I did, but not anymore. Hopefully we see clearer and further now then in 1980, and certainly in 1970, which is as the current cliché goes, “a good thing”.
If all of this seems to be strangely convoluted, you are quite right. But then so is life and art and art often mirrors life and occasionally vice versa. So in our modern world of 2012, we are tempted to say what is the big deal? The big deal is in retrospect the modernity of “Carpenters” music. In my opinion the reason that their music was so derided in its time is that it was in fact futuristic and as such, hardly suited to the orthodoxy of the 70’s, its society and mores and what was expected, actually required for music. It is certainly beyond its time. If you listen to the orchestration and the instrumentation I’m sure you will be surprised at its modernity. It is staggeringly current and still futuristic, in my opinion.
As an example, music in 1972 does not sound all that different from music in 2012, in a way that 1932, another interval of forty years, sounds altogether different from 1972’s music. And, as another example, there was the “surprise”. I remember it well and it planted a seed, which has lain dormant, and as you can see recently sprouted. It was Karen’s duet with Ella Fitzgerald on their short lived TV show in 1980. Their duet was of Leon Russell’s “Masquerade”. It was a then unnoticed, yet dangerously prescient love song sung between two women, one black, one white. If today you read the lyrics you may, even now, be shocked. I’m not sure the Great American Public at the time even noticed it, or ever caught on. But I did. It was very, very daring, and did a lot to redeem “Carpenters” in my eyes.
So in 2012, I now feel safe to admit that the guilt has finally gone although the pleasure has remained and thankfully and maybe for you too. So with apologies and many thanks to both Karen and Richard Carpenter, “We’ve only just begun”…
bill littlefield
2/2/12